Should UPI be free? Any network that moves trillions of rupees a month needs funding. The real question is who pays and how.
UPI was never free. For six years the government paid through subsidies, banks through their technology budgets and depositors through lower interest on their savings. RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra put it well: “It is not free even now; someone is paying for it.” The new Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) makes that cost visible.
UPI processed over 24,000 crore transactions worth about Rs 314 lakh crore ($3.31 trillion) in FY26, and 14,500 crore worth Rs 177 lakh crore ($1.86 trillion) between April and September 2026. UPI handles about half the world’s real-time payments by volume, according to the IMF. Bank of International settlements (BIS) in July, mentions that fast payment systems with zero user fees and mandatory participation grow quickly, but the private firms that run them are challenged for want of revenue.
Comparing to some of the international payment systems- at 0.4% on payments above Rs 2,000, UPI’s MDR is below Indonesia’s QRIS (0.7% for larger merchants) and Chinese wallets (about 0.6%), close to Brazil’s Pix (roughly 0.22–0.33%), and a fraction of what cards cost. In India, vendors receiving up to Rs 1 lakh a month pay no charges and railways, fuel, utilities and insurance pay a flat Rs 5.
India's charge is free up to Rs 2,000 ($21) which is about four times Indonesia’s. As per NPCI over 96% of merchant transactions by count stay free. In this, a merchant receiving Rs 75,000 by NEFT pays nothing; by UPI, the same receipt would cost Rs 300 plus GST.
Merchant UPI payments in August 26, came to about Rs 8.95 lakh crore ($94 billion), of which about Rs 6 lakh crore ($63 billion) was above Rs 2,000. Allowing for the sectors which has flat Rs 5 as charges and the cap, the effective rate is roughly about 0.15–0.20%, which roughly gives a pool of Rs 12,500 crore ($1.32 billion) a year. Under the present formula, issuer banks take 40%, acquirers 30%, apps 20% and payer PSPs, the sponsor banks that connect apps to UPI, 10%. Banks could end up with as much as 60 to 70%.
Today, PhonePe and Google Pay hold about 80% of its user-facing market, as per the BIS bulletin. Together they would collect about Rs 2,100 crore ($221 million) a year. The BIS state that once a market has moved towards a few players, interoperability alone may not bring back the distribution to an even level... NPCI announced a 30% volume cap on any single app- in November 2020, but this has been deferred three times and is still not enforced six years on as tough to move the customers away.
An IMF note adds that payments give large technology firms steady income and data to cross-sell credit and other services. This fee, which is meant to cover the cost incurred, would end up financing the two leaders’ wider ambitions. The other aspect is GST which at 18% applies to only the MDR and not to the total payment amount. At the max cap, the merchant pays ₹354. Registered merchants claim it back as input credit. The real cost is for those merchants who cannot claim it back – (like composition dealers and merchants who sell exempt goods.
The passing of the charge to the customer, will not stop merchants raising prices, so the buyer of a Rs 500 charger may end up paying for the Rs 50,000 phone. And charging even Rs 5 on one-off loan repayments above Rs 2,000, after years of moving microfinance borrowers away from cash, is a retrograde step. The surcharge ban won’t stop shops raising prices instead, so the buyer of a Rs 500 charger quietly helps pay for the Rs 50,000 phone.
Suggestions:
Let the fee be fixed at Rs 100 for now, (pre-2020), and reset it every two years on audited cost data, a la US Federal Reserve does for debit cards. BIS says that such data is not available now and the Banks and NPCI should fix this immediately.
Let RBI, not NPCI, set the rate, as it does for debit cards, NEFT and RTGS. NPCI is owned by the banks that collect most of the fee.
Reduce the app share as volumes rise, so the largest players earn less per transaction, and let RBI set the tiers after public consultation. Unlike a volume cap, a taper works through price.
Publish each year who received how much payment.
Drop the Rs 5 on loan repayments. A repayment is not a purchase.
Hold acquiring banks answerable for surcharges and raise the Rs 2,000 and Rs 1 lakh limits with inflation.
NPCI has deferred the rollout past Diwali, and a public interest petition is pending in the Supreme Court. Use the time to fix the design rather than reopen whether a charge should exist. UPI won the trust of hundreds of millions of Indians because it was simple and fair. Its price must meet the same test.
(Sriram Kalyanaraman, Partner – BFSI and Advisor, Practus)
(Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of YourStory.)

