A consumer commission has ordered Reliance Retail to pay Rs 7,500 because JioMart sent part of a customer’s refund to a reward wallet after promising to return it to her original payment method. The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Panchkula held Reliance Retail Limited and Reliance Smart Superstore liable for deficiency in service and unfair trade practice in an order dated October 28.
“A consumer cannot be compelled to accept wallet credit in place of a refund to the original mode of payment, particularly when the opposite parties had represented that the amount would be refunded through the original payment mode,” the order said.
The commission also said the practice “raises an issue of deceptive trade practice in the form of a dark pattern,” because wallet credit “may induce the consumer to undertake another transaction through the same platform.” It cited the Central Consumer Protection Authority’s (CCPA) Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023.
What happened?
- The orders: Nishtha Raghav, a Panchkula resident, ordered groceries on JioMart on January 23 and 25, 2026. On both occasions, a Rs 19 chocolate bar was unavailable.
- The payment: She paid for each order mostly through UPI, with Re 1 paid through her Twid (Pay with Rewards) account.
- The refund: JioMart told her it had initiated a Rs 19 refund to her original payment method. However, only Rs 18 reached her bank account each time, while Re 1 went to her Twid account.
- The complaint: JioMart closed her in-app grievance without providing relief, and Reliance did not act on her legal notice. She then approached the commission.
Why did the commission rule against Reliance?
- Different forms of money: The commission said “a bank account and a reward wallet are distinct modes of holding and utilising monetary value.”
- No consent: Reliance produced no evidence that Raghav had agreed to wallet credit or accepted a refund policy allowing it.
- Repeated conduct: The same thing happened with both orders, so the commission ruled out an accounting error.
What must Reliance pay?
- Rs 2,500 to Raghav as compensation.
- Rs 5,000 as punitive damages, to Haryana’s Free Legal Aid State Commission.
Both companies must pay within 45 days. Reliance appeared through counsel but did not file a written statement despite several opportunities, so the commission struck off its defence on June 26.
What do the rules say about refunds?
The Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 require platforms to pay accepted refunds “within a reasonable period of time.” They do not specify which payment method the refund must go to.
The CCPA has intervened on this issue before. In 2024, it directed Ola to give customers the choice between a bank refund and a coupon, after finding that Ola “only provided a coupon code for the next ride.”
So far, the CCPA has imposed penalties of about Rs 1.12 crore on 47 e-commerce platforms, and 31 platforms have declared that they comply with the dark patterns guidelines, according to a Lok Sabha reply in August.
What does the order mean?
- A platform’s promise counts: The order turns on what JioMart told the customer. If a platform promises to refund money to the original payment method but sends part of it elsewhere without consent, it can amount to a deficiency in service, however small the amount.
- The reach is limited: The order binds only the parties involved and stops short of a formal dark pattern finding. Still, a CCPA direction could change refund practices across platforms, as the Ola notice did.
Also Read:
- CCPA Probes Zomato, Swiggy Over Losing Up To 90% On Refunds
- CCPA fines Ola Rs 10 lakh for ‘confirm shaming’ tip prompts
The post Refunds to app wallets without consent may be a dark pattern, consumer commission says in JioMart case appeared first on MEDIANAMA.
