The Karnataka High Court has refused to quash criminal proceedings initiated by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) against Razorpay Whole-Time Director Harshil Mathur and Managing Director Shashank Kumar over alleged lapses in merchant onboarding, Know Your Customer (KYC) verification, due diligence and transaction monitoring. In an order dated November 4, 2026, Justice M. Nagaprasanna rejected their petition challenging the proceedings, which accuse them of failing to discharge their duties as directors under Section 166 of the Companies Act, 2013.

What the court observed: The High Court held that the allegations against Mathur and Kumar, including whether they fulfilled their fiduciary duties and conducted due diligence while onboarding Mad Elephant Network Technology Private Limited (MENTPL), could only be examined during trial.

“Whether such fiduciary duty is complied with by the petitioners or whether due diligence is done by the petitioners or otherwise is a disputed question of fact, which can only be considered at the stage of trial,” Justice Nagaprasanna observed.

The directors argued that Razorpay itself had not been made an accused in the complaint. However, the court noted that the matter was still at a “nascent stage” and that Razorpay’s role could emerge through further investigation.

The court also held that it could not conduct a mini-trial while exercising its jurisdiction under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS).

“It is by now too well settled that this Court, while exercising its jurisdiction under Section 528 of the BNSS, cannot embark upon a mini-trial and adjudicate upon disputed questions of fact by entering into the merits of allegations,” it said.

The court concluded: “It is for the petitioners to come out clean in a full-blown trial. I do not find any warrant of interference at this juncture.”

What the SFIO is investigating: The proceedings originate from a confidential report by the Registrar of Companies (RoC), which allegedly uncovered a network of shell companies with dummy directors created by Jilian Consultants India Private Limited (JCIPL), a wholly owned subsidiary of Fininty Private Limited.

On September 9, 2022, the Central Government ordered an investigation into JCIPL and 32 other companies under Section 212 of the Companies Act. The SFIO submitted its investigation report to the government on July 31, 2024.

One of the companies under investigation was MENTPL, incorporated on November 15, 2019, through JCIPL. According to the complaint, MENTPL allegedly arranged dummy directors controlled by Chinese entities and entered into an arrangement with X10 Financial Services Limited, a non-banking financial company, to provide lending services through digital platforms and mobile applications.

The complaint alleges that MENTPL employed predatory and coercive loan recovery practices, generating wrongful gains of Rs 56.63 crore. The SFIO also alleged that Razorpay acted as a conduit for approximately Rs 320 crore in MENTPL transactions.

Razorpay’s arguments: Mathur and Kumar challenged the SFIO’s jurisdiction, arguing that the investigation under Section 212 should remain confined to the companies specifically named in the Central Government’s order. They contended that Razorpay was not among the companies under investigation.

Their counsel, Senior Advocate Sandesh J. Chouta, also argued that KYC obligations rested with banks rather than payment intermediaries such as Razorpay. He contended that negligence in merchant onboarding did not, by itself, constitute a criminal offence and that the directors could not be held vicariously liable in the absence of specific allegations against them.

The petitioners further argued that the proceedings were barred by limitation and that the Bengaluru court had improperly taken cognisance of the complaint under the BNSS. The Union of India, represented by Additional Solicitor General K. Arvind Kamath, opposed the petition, arguing that Section 212(14) of the Companies Act permits prosecution of persons directly or indirectly connected with the affairs of an investigated company.

The High Court rejected the petition as lacking merit. It did not adjudicate the truth of the allegations against the directors, leaving the disputed issues to be examined during trial.

Also read:

The post Karnataka HC refuses to quash case against Razorpay directors over alleged KYC, monitoring, and merchant onboarding lapses appeared first on MEDIANAMA.